More Pages: Hardy Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66


Cruel and Depressing Novel
I was so passionate, I wrote in the margin...

(Addition to my already posted review)
"The Magus of the North" in THREE CRITICSThe question of Hamann's relation to the Enlightenment turns on the conception of reason. I have maintained that Hamann employed a mode of reason distinct from that of the rationalistic Enlighteners as well as from that of his friendly adversary,Kant. In order to designate that mode, I adopted a term once used by Kant in referring to Hamann's thought,i.e., "intuitive reason," or, in the original German, "anschauende Vernunft." I accepted the term as an apt one for Hamann's mode of thought, however Kant felt about it. Further, I have demonstrated how it can be linguistically distinguished from the traditional logico-mathematical mode of thought in my book "The Quarrel of Reason with Itself"(1988),and elsewhere. It is one which Berlin rightly sees as akin to Dilthey's "verstehen," which Berlin also rejects. He lists a group of philosophers whose conception of reason matches his own: Jeremy Bentham, J.S. Mill, Franz von Brentano, William James, Bertrand Russell and the "Vienna Circle." Most of these thinkers are about as far removed from any kind of "verstehen" as possible. Who then, besides Hamann, may be said to have employed what I have called "intuitive reason"? The prime examples are the great epistemological heirs of Hamann: Goethe and Nietzsche. Goethe belongs here because of his refusal to analyze the "Urphaenomen." Hence, his anti-Newtonian stance. Nietzsche, especially in "Zarathustra," which I have analyzed closely from the standpoint of intuitive reason in "Nietzsche and the Judaeo-Christian Tradition"(1985).
Having stated my reservations concerning Berlin's interpretation of Hamann, I must say, however, that we can be grateful that he has helped mightily to rescue that German philosopher from the obscurity to which he has been unjustly relegated by those who remain under the spell of the strictly rationalistic wing of the Enlightenment. Berlin, in spite of his basic lack of empathy with Hamann, not only recognized his importance, but was always fascinated by him. He was an early and enthusiastic subscriber to "The Hamann News-Letter," which I edited and published in the early 195O's and 196O's. Further, his correspondence with me regarding Hamann over a period of three and a half decades shows an unflagging interest in the man who both attracted and repelled him. In a letter to me of June 25,1972, he wrote: "My passion for Hamann is undiminished." Not too surprisingly, there are certain passages in the present book in which Berlin seems, unwittingly, to move toward a certain degree of empathy,hence to a kind of "verstehen." But such passages are few, and many others are unjustly harsh. Nevertheless, for all its shortcomings, Berlin's study of Hamann is valuable for introducing the reader, especially the anglophone reader, to the historically important pre-Romantic figure, known as "The Magus of the North," without whom the development of German Romanticism would be unthinkable, and whose insights increasingly bear fruit today, especially in theology and philosophy. As Berlin has said: "Hamann repays study."


too costly
Excellent reference and educational book

More touchy-feely than a bowl of peeled grapesAs a reference, this book stinks. The author will not define the "voice envelope" where if you stay within the envelope users will have a hard time perceiving a loss in quality. For example, this book is touted as useful to VoIP Network Architects, but the book gives absolutely no guidance as to what is an acceptable (or unacceptable) level of delay in a VoIP phone system.
Instead, the author wastes 309 pages and about .01% of a perfectly good tree, to say, basically, "nobody can evaluate voice quality without running a side-by-side experiment between two systems." Its a wonder that someone can publish 309 pages of this drivil with one conclusion for his entire work. Oh, I forgot, the author fills up the book with 67 pages that are wasted in his bragging about all his patents, when he filed them, and what each and every last patent was about. If that isn't vanity publishing, I don't know what is.
Understand what really matters for VoIP qualityAs more and more voice traffic is transmitted over packet-switched networks, the challenges to producing high-quality voice services at a low cost are increasing, thanks to the increasing complexity of the networks involved. There are corresponding pay-offs, however, for the equipment vendors and service providers that do learn how to meet these challenges. Not only should they be able to provide the equivalent of voice network's service for lower costs, they should also be able to offer new services that combine voice and data in ways that attract new customers -- and boost revenues. Conversely, as long as these challenges go unmet, or in many cases, unrecognized, they will slow the rate at which the promises of the new technology can be realized. Working as I do in a company striving to break through these barriers to success, it is heartening to find a book like this one that helps show the way.
VoIP Service Quality comprises three principal sections. The first lays out foundations for what follows. It starts by discussing the principal determinants of connection quality, especially in voice packet-switched networks. It next lays out how customer expectations for voice quality differ among the different services that can be offered with such networks, and closes with a description of the quality impairments that can be created or exacerbated by packet switching. The second section concerns the measurement and evaluation of voice quality. It offers value not only to those who are interested in the quality of packet-switched voice, but also those who are concerned with it in today's public switched telephone network. It shows how statistically rigorous, operationally useful quality testing can be set up in a network with minimal investment. It goes on to discuss a variety of automated test approaches, and lays out the benefits and defects of each. The third section outlines other quality concerns and points the way for measurement of voice quality in future, yet-to-be-defined services that combine voice and data. Those who are interested by this section would do well to read the author's previous book, the somewhat misleadingly entitled *QoS Measurement and Evaluation of Telecommunications Quality of Service*.
At the end of this voyage, the reader will have the complete conceptual structure needed to set up a voice service quality organization. Books like this one that lay out an arcane field in clear English are rare, especially since a good measure of humor is thrown in to ease the way. I recommend VoIP Service Quality highly.


An Average Book
Loss of appeal

A Bridge Book for Experts Only

A Bit Better Than Average

Some good, Some boring

Good action description, above average storylines

Different, But Enjoyable